Best Carry on Luggage: Our Top 10 Picks & Reviews

Introduction

Navigating the world of carry-on luggage can be a daunting task, but after extensive testing and analysis, we’ve found the clear winner for most travelers. The Samsonite Omni PC Expandable Carry-On Luggage stands out as our top pick for its exceptional blend of durability, maneuverability, and value. Its tough polycarbonate shell resisted scratches in our tests, the spinner wheels glided effortlessly across airport floors, and the built-in TSA lock provided peace of mind. For a reliable, stylish, and practical travel companion that won’t break the bank, the Omni PC is simply unmatched.

Our Top 10 Picks for Best Carry on Luggage

#1 Samsonite Omni PC Expandable Carry-On Luggage – Ideal for: The All-Around Traveler Seeking Durability and Value

After putting numerous bags through their paces, we can confidently say the Samsonite Omni PC Expandable Carry-On Luggage is the best all-around choice for most travelers. The first thing we noticed was its construction. The micro-diamond textured polycarbonate shell feels incredibly robust and lived up to its scratch-resistant claim, showing minimal wear even after being deliberately scuffed. This is a sentiment echoed by many users who noted its ability to maintain its appearance trip after trip. At just under 7 pounds, it strikes an excellent balance between lightweight design and solid protection.

Maneuverability is where this case truly shines. The four oversized spinner wheels glide effortlessly, allowing for 360-degree mobility that makes navigating a crowded terminal a breeze. We could push it alongside us with just a fingertip, a significant upgrade from older two-wheeled models. Inside, the clamshell design features a zippered divider on one side and compression straps on the other, keeping everything secure. While we, and some users, wish it had a few more small interior pockets, using packing cubes easily solves this. The side-mounted TSA lock is a crucial feature, offering security without the need for a separate padlock. The expansion zipper also provides valuable extra space for those last-minute souvenirs. For its price, durability, and smooth performance, the Samsonite Omni PC Expandable Carry-On Luggage is a clear winner.

#2 Travelpro Maxlite 5 Underseat Carry-On Tote – Perfect for: The Minimalist Weekend or as a Personal Item

For travelers who pack light or need the perfect companion to their rolling suitcase, the Travelpro Maxlite 5 Underseat Carry-On Tote is an outstanding choice. We were immediately impressed by how feather-light it is—at just 1.6 pounds, it’s barely noticeable. Despite its weight, the polyester fabric feels durable, and the Duraguard coating effectively repelled water in our tests. This isn’t just a simple tote; it’s a well-structured bag that holds its shape, making it easy to pack and access your items. Our experience was confirmed by several users who appreciated that it fit perfectly under the seats of various major airlines, even on smaller regional jets.

Organization is surprisingly robust for its compact size. The main compartment is roomy enough for a change of clothes, toiletries, and a book. We found the multiple exterior and interior pockets perfect for stashing a passport, charging cables, and snacks. One of its best features is the rear strap that allows it to slide securely over the handle of a larger rolling bag, a detail many travelers found indispensable for a consolidated airport dash. While the strap’s Velcro closure could be wider for added security on wider handles, it held firm in our tests with a standard carry-on. If you need a versatile, ultra-light bag that maximizes your personal item allowance, the Travelpro Maxlite 5 Underseat Carry-On Tote is a fantastic and highly functional option.

#3 Rockland London 20-Inch Hardside Spinner Luggage – Suits: Budget-Conscious Travelers Who Don’t Want to Sacrifice Style

The Rockland London 20-Inch Hardside Spinner Luggage proves that you don’t have to spend a fortune to get a functional and stylish carry-on. We were immediately struck by its incredibly light weight—at just 5 pounds, it was one of the lightest hardside spinners we tested. The ABS material, while not as robust as polycarbonate, held up reasonably well to our standard impact tests, though it is more prone to scuffs, a point noted by long-term users. However, for the price, the durability is more than adequate for the average vacationer. The double spinner wheels are a major plus, offering smooth 360-degree rolling that makes it easy to navigate through tight spaces.

Inside, the Rockland London 20-Inch Hardside Spinner Luggage offers a simple but effective layout with a zippered divider and elastic garment straps to keep belongings in place. The telescopic handle feels a little less sturdy than those on premium models, but it locked into place securely and functioned without issue during our trials. We found it met the carry-on sizer bin requirements for major domestic airlines without a problem. Many users praised its perfect size and surprisingly spacious interior, easily holding enough for a long weekend trip. If you’re looking for an affordable, lightweight spinner that gets the job done and comes in a variety of eye-catching colors, this Rockland model offers fantastic value.

#4 Kenneth Cole REACTION 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Suitcase – Ideal for: The Organized Packer Needing a Large Checked Bag

When you need to pack for a week or more, the Kenneth Cole REACTION 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Suitcase is a fantastic checked-bag option that prioritizes organization. What we loved most about this suitcase is its thoughtfully designed interior. Unlike many hardside cases with a simple 50/50 split, this one features a large U-shaped zipper pocket, a full-length mesh pocket, and a compression panel to keep your clothes securely in place and wrinkle-free. We were able to pack for a 10-day trip with room to spare, especially after using the 2-inch expansion feature. The ABS and PC composite shell, reinforced with molded corner guards, provided excellent protection for our belongings.

The eight spinner wheels delivered a smooth and quiet glide across various surfaces, from smooth airport linoleum to bumpy sidewalks, a performance that many users highlighted as a key benefit for such a large bag. The telescoping handle felt sturdy, and the flexible top and side grab handles made lifting the 11.5-pound suitcase into a car trunk manageable. A minor design flaw we noticed, which a few users also pointed out, is that the side grab handle can sometimes pinch your hand if you’re not careful. However, this is a small issue on an otherwise stellar piece of luggage. For travelers who value interior organization and durable construction in a large checked bag, the Kenneth Cole REACTION 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Suitcase is an excellent and reliable choice.

#5 DELSEY PARIS Helium Aero 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Luggage – Perfect for: Travelers Wanting a Stylish and Durable Large Checked Bag

The DELSEY PARIS Helium Aero 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Luggage exudes a premium feel from the moment you handle it. We were immediately drawn to its deep, glossy metallic finish, which looks sophisticated and high-end. But it’s not just about looks; the 100% polycarbonate shell is built for toughness. It flexes under pressure to absorb impact, which helps prevent the cracking that can plague cheaper hard plastics. During our tests, it proved highly resilient, a finding confirmed by a user who reported their bag survived six years of full-time travel.

Mobility is top-notch, thanks to the eight double spinner wheels that provide a stable, smooth glide. The bag feels surprisingly light on its feet for its size. The interior is well-appointed with two fully-lined packing compartments, tie-down straps, and a zippered divider to keep items separate and organized. We particularly appreciated the integrated 3-dial TSA-accepted lock, which adds a layer of security and convenience. The 2-inch expansion feature is a welcome addition for longer trips. One critique we share with some users is the telescoping handle can feel a bit wobbly when fully extended, but it never failed us during testing. For those seeking a blend of Parisian style, robust protection, and smooth performance in a large checked bag, the DELSEY PARIS Helium Aero 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Luggage is a superb investment.

#6 Samsonite Omni 2 Expandable Hardshell Carry-On Luggage – Suits: International Flyers Needing a Compact and Compliant Carry-On

When traveling abroad, carry-on size restrictions can be much stricter, and that’s where the Samsonite Omni 2 Expandable Hardshell Carry-On Luggage excels. We measured it carefully and found its dimensions are noticeably more compact than its predecessor, the Omni PC, making it an ideal choice for fitting into the sizer bins of budget European airlines. This observation was validated by several users who specifically bought it for international travel and reported no issues with compliance. The scratch-resistant polycarbonate shell has a modern, clean look and provides solid protection for your belongings, though it does feel slightly more flexible than the original Omni.

The four spinner wheels roll smoothly, making airport navigation easy. The interior layout is standard for a hardside, with a zippered divider on one side and compression straps on the other. A modern feature we liked is the built-in charging port system, which allows you to connect your own power bank internally and charge devices on the go. However, the standout feature is its size. While some domestic travelers might find it a bit small for a week-long trip, we found it perfect for a 3-5 day journey. It forces you to pack efficiently, ensuring you’ll never be forced to gate-check your bag on an international flight. For the frequent international traveler, the Samsonite Omni 2 Expandable Hardshell Carry-On Luggage offers peace of mind and reliable performance.

#7 Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable Carry-On Luggage – Ideal for: The Frequent Business Traveler Who Demands Premium Features

The Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable Carry-On Luggage is a masterclass in softside luggage design, clearly built with the frequent flyer in mind. From the moment we started rolling it, the difference was palpable. The patented Precision Glide System, with its self-aligning magnetic wheels, is genuinely exceptional. The suitcase glides straight as an arrow and feels incredibly stable. The PowerScope extension handle is rock-solid with zero wobble, and the contoured grip is comfortable to hold for long walks through the terminal. It’s no surprise this brand is a favorite among flight crews.

The organizational features are second to none. We were particularly impressed with the drop-in, fold-out suiter, which kept a blazer and dress shirt remarkably wrinkle-free. The built-in USB-A and USB-C ports, connected to an internal FAA-compliant power bank pocket, are a lifesaver for staying charged. The high-density nylon fabric with DuraGuard coating is tough and resists stains and abrasions. We easily packed for a 5-day business trip with room to spare, thanks to the efficient layout and 2-inch expansion. One user amusingly noted the wheels are so smooth the bag might roll away on an incline, a testament to their quality. While it comes at a premium price, the durability, flawless mobility, and thoughtful features of the Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable Carry-On Luggage make it a worthwhile investment for any serious traveler.

#8 Samsonite Centric 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Luggage – Perfect for: Travelers Needing a Lightweight but Large Checked Bag

For extended trips requiring a checked bag, weight is a critical factor, and the Samsonite Centric 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Luggage delivers impressive capacity without tipping the scales. Made from 100% polycarbonate, it felt both lightweight and sturdy in our hands. The twill texture does an excellent job of hiding scuffs and scratches, a common complaint with glossy hardside luggage. We found it to be a very reliable and practical choice for a 9-day cruise, easily holding all necessary clothing and gear while staying under the airline’s 50-pound limit.

The 360-degree spinner wheels rolled comfortably, though we noticed they weren’t quite as buttery-smooth as some premium models, particularly on carpeted surfaces. This was a minor point also raised by a few users, but the performance was still more than adequate. The interior features a standard clamshell design with a mesh divider and compression straps, which effectively keeps contents organized. The integrated TSA combination lock is a great touch for security and convenience. We also appreciated the expansion feature, which provides that crucial extra bit of packing space. For travelers who need a large, durable, and relatively lightweight checked bag from a trusted brand, the Samsonite Centric 28-Inch Expandable Hardside Luggage offers solid performance and great value.

#9 Rockland Safari Hardside Carry-On Spinner Luggage – Suits: Style-Conscious Travelers on a Budget

The Rockland Safari Hardside Carry-On Spinner Luggage is all about making a statement without draining your wallet. We tested the leopard print version, and its vibrant design is definitely an eye-catcher, making it easy to spot. But beyond its bold aesthetics, it’s a surprisingly functional carry-on for its price. The polycarbonate/ABS composite shell is extremely lightweight, which we loved for lifting it into overhead bins. It’s important to note that the shell has considerable flex and is best suited for carry-on use rather than being checked, as it might not withstand the rigors of baggage handling. Many users purchased it for this exact purpose and were pleased with its performance on flights.

The eight spinner wheels provided a fluid and quiet roll, a feature we were happy to see at this price point. The interior is nicely appointed with a zippered divider that includes its own mesh and elastic pockets, offering better organization than many budget competitors. One common point of feedback, and something we experienced firsthand, is the protective plastic film it ships with is very difficult to remove completely, often leaving small pieces around the edges. While this is a temporary annoyance, the bag itself performs well. For travelers who prioritize fashion and need a lightweight, affordable carry-on for shorter trips, the Rockland Safari Hardside Carry-On Spinner Luggage is a fun and practical choice.

#10 Amazon Basics 35-inch Rolling Duffle Bag – Ideal for: Hauling Large or Awkwardly-Shaped Gear

When a traditional suitcase just won’t cut it, the Amazon Basics 35-inch Rolling Duffle Bag steps in with massive capacity and flexible storage. This bag is enormous, offering 137 liters of space, making it perfect for long trips, sports equipment, or family travel where you need to consolidate gear. We were impressed by the durable ripstop polyester material, which felt rugged and built to last. The multiple zippered compartments, including a large main section and several exterior pockets, make it easy to organize your belongings.

The bag features two in-line skate-style wheels that are robust and handled rough surfaces better than typical spinner wheels. The trade-off is that you have to pull it behind you, which can be less convenient than a spinner. We found the telescoping handle to be sturdy, and the multiple grab handles made it easy to lift. One key design point we noted, which was also a common theme in user feedback, is that the duffle needs to be fully packed to stand upright on its own; otherwise, it tends to tip over. While its own weight of nearly 12 pounds is considerable, its sheer volume and durable build make it an excellent choice for anyone needing to transport a large amount of gear without the rigid constraints of a hardside suitcase. One user, a traveling lineman, praised its toughness and ample room for boots and work gear, confirming its utility for heavy-duty use.

The Ultimate Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose The Right Product for You

Key Factors to Consider

• Size and Weight: Always check your airline’s specific carry-on size restrictions before buying. Domestic US airlines typically allow bags up to 22 x 14 x 9 inches. The weight of the bag itself is also crucial, as a lighter bag allows you to pack more without exceeding weight limits.
• Material (Hardside vs. Softside): Hardside luggage (polycarbonate or ABS) offers better protection for fragile items and is often more water-resistant. Softside luggage (nylon or polyester) is more flexible, allowing you to squeeze in extra items, and often features convenient exterior pockets.
• Wheels (2 vs. 4): Four-wheeled “spinner” luggage offers 360-degree mobility, allowing you to push the bag alongside you effortlessly. This is a huge advantage in tight spaces like airplane aisles. Two-wheeled bags must be pulled behind you, but their recessed wheels can be more durable on rough surfaces like cobblestones.
• Handles: A good telescoping handle should be sturdy with minimal wobble. Check for multiple locking height positions to suit your comfort. Padded top and side grab handles are also essential for easy lifting into overhead bins or car trunks.
• Features: Look for useful extras like expandability for extra packing room, built-in TSA-approved locks for security, and well-designed interior compartments or compression systems to keep your belongings organized.

Understanding Luggage Materials

The material of your suitcase is one of its most important features. Polycarbonate is the premium choice for hardside luggage. It’s incredibly durable, impact-resistant (it can flex and pop back into shape), and very lightweight. ABS is a more common and affordable plastic used in hardside bags. It’s lighter than polycarbonate but less durable and more prone to cracking under stress. For softside luggage, Ballistic Nylon is the top-tier material, known for its extreme durability and resistance to abrasion and tearing. Polyester is a more common and less expensive softside material, sold in various denier counts (a higher number indicates thicker, more durable fabric).

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Ignoring Airline Restrictions: Don’t just assume a bag labeled “carry-on” will be compliant. Always verify the dimensions against the airlines you fly most frequently.
• Overlooking Weight: A heavy empty suitcase eats into your precious packing allowance. Aim for the lightest bag that still meets your durability needs.
• Focusing Only on Capacity: A huge interior is useless if it’s not organized. Look for bags with smart dividers, pockets, and compression straps to make packing more efficient.
• Skimping on Wheels and Handles: These are the components you’ll interact with most and are common points of failure. Test the handle for sturdiness and ensure the wheels roll smoothly before committing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the maximum legal size for a carry-on bag in the US?

While there isn’t a single “legal” size set by law, most major US airlines have converged on a maximum carry-on dimension of 22 x 14 x 9 inches (56 x 36 x 23 cm), including wheels and handles. However, budget airlines and smaller regional jets may have stricter requirements. Always check with your specific airline before you fly.

Is hardside or softside carry-on luggage better?

It depends on your priorities. Hardside luggage offers superior protection for fragile contents and is generally more water-resistant. Softside luggage provides more flexibility, often includes convenient exterior pockets for quick access to items, and can be easier to fit into tight overhead spaces because the material has some give.

Which brand makes the most durable carry-on luggage?

Brands like Samsonite and Travelpro have long-standing reputations for durability and quality. Samsonite is a leader in polycarbonate hardside technology (like our top pick, the Omni PC), while Travelpro is a favorite among airline crews for its rugged softside bags (like the Platinum Elite).

Are spinner wheels (4 wheels) better than 2-wheel carry-ons?

For most travelers, yes. Spinner wheels offer 360-degree mobility, allowing you to effortlessly glide the bag beside you, which is a significant advantage in crowded airports and narrow airplane aisles. Two-wheel bags, which you pull behind you, can perform better on very rough terrain like cobblestones, but the convenience of spinners usually outweighs this benefit for typical travel.

What features should I look for in a quality carry-on?

Look for a sturdy, multi-stage telescoping handle, smooth and durable wheels, strong zippers, a built-in TSA-approved lock, and practical interior organization like compression straps and zippered dividers. An expansion feature can also be very useful for extra packing space on your return trip.

How much should I expect to spend on a good carry-on suitcase?

You can find reliable, good-quality carry-on luggage in the $80 to $180 range. While budget options exist for under $80, they often compromise on wheel and handle durability. Premium models from high-end brands can cost $300 or more, offering superior materials, advanced features, and better warranties.

Is expensive carry-on luggage worth the investment?

For frequent travelers, yes. An expensive suitcase often means better materials (like 100% polycarbonate instead of ABS), superior components (smoother wheels, sturdier handles), and more comprehensive warranties. The improved durability and user experience can make the higher initial cost worthwhile over many years of travel.

Conclusion: Our Final Recommendation

After thorough testing and careful consideration of countless user experiences, we are delighted to reaffirm our top choice. The Samsonite Omni PC Expandable Carry-On Luggage is the best carry-on for the vast majority of travelers. It delivers an outstanding combination of features that matter most: a tough, scratch-resistant polycarbonate shell that protects your belongings, whisper-quiet spinner wheels that make airport navigation a joy, and essential security features like an integrated TSA lock. It perfectly balances premium construction with an accessible price point, making it a smart and reliable investment for both casual vacationers and frequent flyers. It’s the bag we’d choose for our own travels, without hesitation.

Last update on 2025-10-06 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API