I remember a backpacking trip years ago where my feet paid the price for my poor gear choices. I had a pair of monstrously heavy, stiff leather boots that promised bombproof protection. They delivered on protection, but at the cost of my comfort. Every step felt like lifting a small brick, and by day two, I had blisters forming on my heels that turned a beautiful mountain vista into a landscape of misery. That experience taught me a crucial lesson: the “best” boot isn’t always the toughest or most expensive; it’s the one that disappears on your feet, letting you focus on the journey. This is the elusive sweet spot every hiker, from the weekend warrior to the daily commuter, seeks: a boot that offers rugged support and waterproofing without the weight and rigidity of a traditional mountaineering boot. The challenge is finding one that can handle a muddy trail on Saturday and a rainy walk to the office on Monday without missing a beat.
- ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY: Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot features our lightweight, durable midsole for long lasting comfort,...
- HANDY FEATURES: Treacherous days out on the trail are comfortable and worry-free with this boot's waterproof full-grain leather and mesh bootie...
What to Consider Before Buying a Hiking Boot
A hiking boot is more than just footwear; it’s a key piece of equipment that serves as the foundation for your entire outdoor experience. It’s the critical link between you and the ground, responsible for providing stability, traction, and protection from the elements. The right pair can prevent slips and falls on treacherous terrain, keep your feet dry during unexpected downpours, and absorb the relentless impact of miles on the trail, preventing fatigue and injury. Choosing incorrectly, however, can lead to discomfort, blisters, and a premature end to an otherwise perfect adventure.
The ideal customer for a boot like the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot is someone who values versatility. This includes day hikers, weekend campers, individuals who work on their feet across varied surfaces, and even urban dwellers looking for a stylish, weatherproof boot for the colder months. They need reliable performance without committing to a highly specialized, and often much heavier, piece of gear. On the other hand, this type of boot might not be suitable for those who engage in serious mountaineering, multi-week thru-hiking with heavy packs, or intense manual labor in harsh industrial environments. These users would require boots with stiffer soles, more robust ankle support, and premium, abrasion-resistant materials that come at a higher price point.
Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Fit and Sizing: This is the single most important factor. A boot should be snug but not tight, with enough room in the toe box to wiggle your toes freely. Consider if you’ll be wearing thick wool socks and whether you need a standard or wide width, as a boot that’s too narrow can cause significant pain over long distances.
- Traction and Support: The outsole is your connection to the trail. Look for deep, multi-directional lugs that can grip a variety of surfaces, from wet rock to loose gravel and mud. The midsole provides cushioning and support; technologies like Columbia’s TECHLITE aim to deliver high energy return to reduce fatigue on long hikes.
- Materials and Waterproofing: The upper material dictates the boot’s durability, breathability, and water resistance. Full-grain leather offers maximum durability but can be heavy, while synthetics and mesh are lighter and more breathable. A waterproof membrane, like Omni-TECH, is essential for keeping feet dry in wet conditions, but it’s important to understand it can slightly reduce breathability.
- Weight and Breathability: Every ounce on your feet matters over a long day. Lighter boots, often compared to sneakers in feel, can significantly reduce fatigue. However, this lightness can sometimes come at the cost of long-term durability. A good boot strikes a balance, offering support without feeling like an anchor.
Keeping these factors in mind, the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot stands out in several areas. You can explore its detailed specifications and available sizes here.
While the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot is an excellent choice, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models and how to pair them with the right gear, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- Lightweight 12 L Hydration Backpack: Super lightweight 8.5 oz hydration pack backpack with 2 L water bladder. Waterproof and tear-resistant fabric, PU...
- ESSENTIALS FOR EMERGENCY: Everything you need is in this first aid kit! Our kit includes over 150 professional-grade medical and safety supplies, all kinds...
- Stay cool, fresh and comfortable all day with our lightweight, breathable, water-resistant and quick-dry women's hiking pants.
Unboxing the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II: First Look and Feel
Pulling the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot out of the box, the first thing I noticed was its surprisingly low weight. In the Cordovan/Squash colorway, it has a classic, handsome look that doesn’t scream “technical gear,” making it immediately appealing for casual wear. The PU-coated leather upper has a smooth, consistent finish, and the contrasting squash-colored accents on the collar and laces add a welcome pop of color. The metal lacing hardware feels sturdy and well-anchored. Unlike many beefier hiking boots that feel stiff and unforgiving out of the box, the Newton Ridge II had a noticeable flex in the sole and a pliable feel around the ankle collar. It felt less like a rigid hiking boot and more like a high-top sneaker built for the outdoors, an impression that was strongly reinforced the moment I put them on.
What We Like
- Incredible out-of-the-box comfort with virtually no break-in period required.
- Surprisingly lightweight design reduces fatigue on long walks and hikes.
- Excellent value for the price, offering reliable waterproofing and traction.
- Versatile style that works equally well on the trail and for everyday urban wear.
Potential Drawbacks
- PU-coated leather may not offer the long-term durability of premium full-grain leather under heavy use.
- The outsole, while grippy, is made of a softer rubber that could wear down faster with daily, high-mileage use on abrasive surfaces.
In the Field: A Deep Dive into the Newton Ridge Plus II’s Performance
A boot can look great in the box, but its true character is only revealed on the trail. We put the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot through its paces over several weeks, subjecting it to a range of conditions: muddy spring trails, rocky creek beds, long days on pavement, and even a surprise late-season dusting of snow. Our goal was to push past the spec sheet and discover how its core technologies—comfort, traction, and waterproofing—perform in the real world.
Comfort and Fit: A Sneaker-Like Feel Straight From the Box?
The most common praise I’d heard about the Newton Ridge II, echoed by numerous users, was its “out-of-the-box comfort.” I can confirm this is not an exaggeration. From the moment I first laced them up, there was none of the stiffness or awkwardness that typically signals a painful “break-in period.” The interior is well-padded, especially around the ankle collar and the durable mesh tongue, which prevents the laces from digging into the top of the foot. The fit is true to size for my average-width feet, though I appreciated the availability of a ‘Wide’ option, as noted by users who prefer extra room for thicker socks or have broader feet. One user aptly stated they “fit like a dream” and couldn’t tell the difference between them and his running sneakers—a sentiment I completely understand.
The secret to this comfort lies in Columbia’s TECHLITE midsole. It provides a remarkable level of cushioning and energy return that you can feel with every step. I wore these boots for an entire day of running errands that ended with a 5-mile hike, racking up well over 15,000 steps. My feet felt supported and fresh, not fatigued and sore as they would have in heavier boots. The arch support is present and effective without being overly aggressive. While some users suggest swapping out the insole for a custom one, I found the stock insole perfectly adequate for moderate hiking and all-day wear. This level of sustained comfort is what makes the boot a standout, transforming it from just a piece of hiking gear into a reliable daily driver.
Omni-GRIP Traction: Conquering Varied Terrains with Confidence
Traction is non-negotiable in a hiking boot, and Columbia’s Omni-GRIP outsole is designed to be an all-terrain performer. I tested its limits on a particularly slick, rain-soaked trail littered with wet roots and mossy rocks. The multi-directional lugs bit into the mud confidently, preventing the kind of lateral slippage that can lead to a nasty fall. On steeper gravel descents, the heel brake zone provided a secure and controlled feeling. The rubber compound is indeed on the softer side, which is a double-edged sword. On one hand, it provides excellent adhesion to smooth, tricky surfaces like wet rock slabs. I was able to confidently hop across a shallow creek without feeling my footing was compromised.
However, as one discerning user pointed out, this softer rubber could lead to faster wear and tear, especially if used daily as a work boot on concrete or asphalt. This is a valid trade-off to consider. The boot is not designed to be a lifetime companion for a warehouse worker or landscaper, but for the intended user—the recreational hiker and everyday adventurer—the grip is exceptional. The specs also mention a “dual-zone winter tread pattern,” and during a light snowfall, I found the traction on slushy sidewalks to be surprisingly good. The non-marking sole is also a nice touch, ensuring you don’t leave scuffs on indoor floors when you transition from the trail to home. For those seeking reliable, multi-surface grip for most three-season conditions, the Omni-GRIP system delivers.
Omni-TECH Waterproofing and Durability: Weathering the Storm
The term “waterproof” gets thrown around a lot, but the Omni-TECH system in the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot is the real deal. It utilizes a seam-sealed membrane bootie construction that creates an impermeable barrier against moisture. My definitive test was an intentional, prolonged standing in a six-inch-deep, ice-cold puddle. My feet remained completely, impressively dry. During a steady rain, water beaded up and rolled right off the PU-coated leather, just as one user described. The durable mesh tongue is also gusseted, preventing water and trail debris from sneaking in around the laces.
Now, let’s talk about that PU-coated leather. This is the feature that positions the boot in its specific market niche. It’s not the thick, rugged full-grain leather you’d find on a premium mountaineering boot that costs three times as much. As one user astutely noted, this isn’t a “workhorse boot” for heavy labor. The PU coating can be more susceptible to scuffs and deep gashes than traditional leather. However, for its intended purpose, it’s a brilliant choice. It’s what makes the boot so light, requires no conditioning, and is incredibly easy to clean. A quick wipe-down with a damp cloth makes them look almost new, a feature praised by a user who wore them for landscaping. When you balance the critiques of its ultimate ruggedness with the stories of users happily wearing their pairs for two, three, and even four years of regular hiking and camping, a clear picture emerges: the durability is more than sufficient for its target audience. If you demand reliable waterproofing without the weight and maintenance of old-school leather, this modern approach to boot construction is a clear winner.
What Other Users Are Saying
Across the board, the feedback for the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot is overwhelmingly positive, centering on a few key themes. The most frequently praised attribute is its immediate comfort. One user who put his pair to heavy use for four years, including month-long camping trips to the Rockies, noted they were “perfect right out of the box. Super comfortable and no break in period required.” Another, who wears them daily for work in a warehouse, called them “one of the best pair of work boots I’ve ever had” because they are so comfortable and light.
However, the critiques, though fewer, are consistent and provide important context. The most insightful feedback comes from a user who clarified, “this shoe is not a workhorse boot.” He pointed to the “poor quality PU coated leather” and a soft outsole that could “wear out quickly” under the demands of a 9-to-5 labor job. This doesn’t contradict the positive reviews but rather defines the boot’s ideal use case. Other minor issues noted by users include a narrower fit for some, requiring them to order a ‘Wide’ size, and occasional discrepancies between the product photos and the real-life color. These comments paint a picture of a fantastic light-to-medium-duty boot that excels in comfort and value but may not be the right choice for the most demanding, high-abrasion environments.
How Does the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Compare to the Competition?
While the Newton Ridge II is a top contender in its class, it’s crucial to see how it measures up against other popular alternatives. Each offers a different set of strengths for different types of users.
1. The North Face Thermoball Traction Mule V Winter Shoe
- SLIP-IN COMFORT: Whether you're at base camp or just stepping out for the paper, the Men's ThermoBall Traction Mule V offers easy, cushioned warmth with...
- WATER-RESISTANT DURABILITY: With a durable ripstop upper made from 100% recycled polyester finished with a non-PFC DWR coating, these insulated shoes repel...
This isn’t a direct competitor but rather a complementary piece of gear. The North Face Mule is the ultimate camp and cabin shoe. It’s an insulated, water-repellent slip-on designed for comfort and warmth after a long day of hiking. While it has a rubber outsole for traction around the campsite, it offers none of the ankle support, waterproofing, or rugged protection of the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot. If you’re looking for a post-hike recovery shoe or a warm option for quick trips outside in the winter, the Mule is fantastic. For actual hiking, the Columbia boot is the only viable choice between the two.
2. Timberland Chocorua Trail Mid Waterproof Boots
- Upper made with waterproof premium Timberland leather and mesh fabric
- Rustproof speed lace hardware with lace hooks at top
The Timberland Chocorua is a more traditional and direct competitor. It often features a premium full-grain leather upper that may offer superior long-term abrasion resistance compared to the Newton Ridge’s PU-coated leather. This makes it a compelling option for users who prioritize rugged durability above all else. However, this robust construction typically comes with added weight and a stiffer feel that requires a more significant break-in period. One user specifically mentioned switching from the Chocorua to the Columbia boot. The choice here is clear: for a classic, potentially more durable boot where you don’t mind extra weight, consider the Timberland. For out-of-the-box comfort and a lighter, more athletic feel, the Newton Ridge II holds the edge.
3. Merrell Men’s Moab 2 Vent Hiking Shoe
- Pigskin leather and mesh upper
- Traditional lace closure
The Merrell Moab is an icon in the hiking world and perhaps the most frequent comparison. The key difference is right in the name: “Vent” versus the Newton Ridge’s “Waterproof.” The Moab 2 Vent is legendary for its breathability, making it a superior choice for hiking in hot, dry climates where moisture wicking is more important than keeping water out. The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot, with its Omni-TECH membrane, is the clear winner for wet, muddy, or unpredictable three-season conditions. While Merrell offers a waterproof version of the Moab, the Columbia boot often represents a better value proposition, delivering comparable performance at a more accessible price point.
Our Final Verdict: Is the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II the Right Boot for You?
After extensive testing and analysis, our verdict is clear: the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot is an exceptional piece of footwear that offers an almost unbeatable combination of comfort, performance, and value. Its greatest strength is its versatility. This is a boot that feels as at home on a slick, muddy trail as it does on city streets during a downpour. The immediate, sneaker-like comfort removes the dread of a break-in period, while the reliable Omni-TECH waterproofing and Omni-GRIP traction provide the confidence needed for most day hikes and weekend adventures.
We wholeheartedly recommend this boot to day hikers, casual campers, and anyone seeking a lightweight, waterproof, and comfortable boot for everyday wear. While it may not be the most durable option for heavy-duty construction work or extreme mountaineering, it was never designed to be. It occupies a brilliant sweet spot, delivering about 80% of the performance of high-end boots at less than half the price. It’s a testament to smart design and a deep understanding of what most people actually need in a hiking boot.
If you’ve decided the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot is the right fit for your adventures, you can check its current price and purchase it here.
Last update on 2025-10-16 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API