There’s a moment every outdoor cooking enthusiast faces. You’ve mastered burgers and steaks on traditional grates, but you dream bigger. You envision a sun-drenched morning, the patio filled with friends, and you at the helm of a sizzling flat top, flipping dozens of pancakes, crisping up pounds of bacon, and searing hash browns to golden perfection—all at once. This was my dream. My trusty kettle grill, as wonderful as it is, just wasn’t built for that kind of high-volume, versatile cooking. The search for an affordable, large-format griddle began, a quest to unlock that next level of backyard culinary freedom without decimating my bank account. The market is flooded with options, but finding one that promises space, power, and portability at a budget-friendly price point is the real challenge. It’s this very dilemma that leads many, including myself, to the doorstep of products like the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill.
- A Must for Outdoor Cooking Enthusiasts: Whether you’re looking for a way of enjoying your outdoor time while accompanied by your favorite meals, or you...
- Includes Convenient Cart: This large gas grill has 4 burners and an optimally sized cooking surface, including a detachable grill cart increasing its...
What to Know Before You Buy a Propane Flat Top Grill
A Propane Grills, specifically a flat top model, is more than just an item; it’s a key solution for unlocking incredible culinary versatility outdoors. Unlike traditional grills with grates, a solid griddle surface opens up a world of possibilities, from delicate eggs and pancakes to hibachi-style vegetables and the perfect crust on a smash burger. It transforms your patio into a short-order kitchen, allowing you to cook entire meals without shuffling pots and pans. The main benefit is the massive, even-heated cooking area that contains messes and vaporizes drippings to create incredible flavor. It’s about efficiency, variety, and the sheer joy of cooking everything in one place.
The ideal customer for this type of product is someone facing the limitations of conventional grilling and craving more surface area and control. They might be a parent who wants to cook a full breakfast for the family outdoors, a foodie who loves experimenting with different cuisines, or an RVer looking for a powerful yet portable cooking station. However, a large flat top grill might not be suitable for those with extremely limited patio space or for individuals who only ever cook for one or two people. Furthermore, anyone who values premium, “buy-it-for-life” build quality and a flawless out-of-the-box experience over a low entry price might want to consider more established, higher-priced brands. The compromises made to achieve a lower price point often manifest in materials and quality control.
Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Dimensions & Space: Measure your available space carefully. A model like the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill boasts a wide 33-inch cooking surface, which is fantastic for capacity but requires a significant footprint. Also, consider the height. Some budget-friendly models can be shorter than premium grills, which might be an ergonomic concern for taller users during long cooking sessions.
- Capacity/Performance: Four burners suggest excellent capacity and the ability to create different temperature zones—for example, searing on one side while keeping food warm on the other. However, the performance is dictated by the quality of the burners (like the “H-pipe” design mentioned by Gas One) and, most importantly, the griddle top itself. A thin or poorly made griddle can warp under high heat, leading to uneven cooking and grease pooling.
- Materials & Durability: Look closely at the materials. “Stainless Steel” can refer to many different grades, and a powder-coated finish is only as good as its application. We’ve seen numerous reports on budget grills where rust appears quickly and the finish flakes off. The griddle top material is paramount; while the product info doesn’t specify, user reviews mention cast iron, which is excellent for heat retention but requires diligent seasoning and care to prevent rust.
- Ease of Use & Maintenance: Think about the entire lifecycle of the grill. How easy is the initial assembly? How straightforward is the seasoning process for the griddle top? Critically, examine the grease management system. An undersized or poorly designed drip tray can lead to messy, hazardous overflows, turning cleanup from a simple task into a major chore.
These considerations are vital in navigating the world of budget flat top grills. It’s a category where price is a major driver, but understanding the potential trade-offs is key to avoiding disappointment.
While the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill is an intriguing option, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- High-Heat Propane Gas BBQ Grill – This 4-burner gas grill with an additional 8,500 BTU side burner delivers a total of 46,500 BTU. Enjoy rapid...
- ❤ STAINLESS STEEL BURNERS: This propane gas grill has 3 Stainless Steel burners, can put out 30,000 BTU-per-hour with integrated piezoelectric ignition...
- Heavy-Duty Griddle Plate – Built with a 4mm thick, reinforced hot-pressed steel griddle that ensures excellent heat retention and durability. Perfect for...
Unboxing the Gas One: A Mixed Bag of First Impressions
The arrival of the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill was an exercise in managed expectations. Pulling the components from the box, a story of compromise began to unfold. On one hand, the concept is fantastic: a large, four-burner griddle with a detachable cart for a very attractive price. On the other hand, the reality of the execution was immediately apparent. Our unit, much like those described by other users, showed signs of a rough journey and questionable quality control. We noticed a few bent frame pieces right away, and several pre-drilled holes didn’t seem to have a perfect relationship with their intended partners.
The powder-coated finish felt thin to the touch, and there were already a few scratches revealing the metal underneath—a concerning omen for its long-term battle with the elements. The griddle top itself was heavy, a good sign, but was covered in a stubbornly adhesive paper over its factory-oiled surface. This wasn’t a simple peel-off sticker; it was a challenge that would require heat, scraping, and patience before we could even think about the first cook. The experience felt less like unboxing a premium appliance and more like starting a weekend project. It was clear from the start that this grill would demand some hands-on effort to get it into working shape.
Advantages
- Spacious four-burner cooking surface offers great capacity
- Detachable cart design enhances portability for camping or tabletop use
- Reaches high temperatures quickly for effective searing
- Very competitive price point for its size and features
Limitations
- Widespread quality control issues (dents, bent parts, misaligned holes)
- Subpar materials and finish lead to premature rusting
- Severely undersized and ineffective grease management system
- Griddle top is prone to warping under heat
Putting the Gas One Grill to the Test: A Performance Breakdown
A grill’s true worth is only revealed through fire, food, and frustration. With the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill, we experienced all three. Moving beyond the initial impressions, we embarked on a comprehensive testing process, from the initial build to the final cleanup, to see if its performance could overcome its problematic beginnings. We wanted to know if this was a diamond in the rough or simply… rough. Our findings paint a picture of a product with immense potential that is tragically held back by its own execution.
The Assembly Gauntlet: A Test of Patience and Ingenuity
The assembly process for the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill proved to be the first major hurdle, confirming the experiences of many frustrated users. Our box arrived missing the instruction manual, forcing us to rely on product photos and mechanical intuition. This immediately set a challenging tone. As we laid out the parts, the quality control issues became glaringly obvious. Several sheet metal components of the cart were bent, requiring us to carefully reshape them with pliers just to get them to fit. The most significant challenge was the hole alignment. On more than one occasion, we had to apply considerable force and creative leverage to persuade bolts to thread into their designated holes, turning a simple task into a frustrating puzzle.
We encountered an issue similar to what one user, a professional in steel fabrication, described: parts that simply shouldn’t have passed inspection. One of the legs was slightly off-angle, giving the entire cart a subtle but noticeable wobble even after everything was tightened. We were also missing one of the four control knobs, a small but essential piece. While some users reported an easy assembly, our experience suggests a profound inconsistency in manufacturing. You might receive a perfectly machined kit, or you might, as we did, receive a project that requires a fair bit of “persuasion” to complete. It is not an experience for the faint of heart or for someone expecting a smooth, 20-minute build.
The Griddle Top Conundrum: Seasoning, Warping, and That Infamous Paper
The heart of any flat top grill is its cooking surface, and the one on the Gas One model presented its own unique set of trials. The first was the protective paper. As many have noted, it was adhered to the pre-oiled surface with incredible tenacity. We followed the advice of a resourceful user and approached it methodically: we heated the griddle on low, which helped loosen the wax-like adhesive. Then, using a plastic scraper and a generous amount of water, we scrubbed the residue away. It was an effective, if messy and time-consuming, process that took nearly 30 minutes. Once clean, the coarse texture of the metal was apparent, and we found a few small spots of surface rust already forming on one edge, confirming fears about the steel’s quality and its susceptibility to the elements.
After a thorough cleaning, we began the crucial seasoning process, applying thin layers of oil and heating them past their smoke point. The grill heated up impressively fast. However, during the third seasoning layer, we heard a distinct “ping” and noticed the center of the griddle had developed a slight upward bow. This warping is a critical flaw. It means that oil and grease no longer spread evenly but instead run towards the edges, creating hotter, drier spots in the middle. This directly impacts cooking consistency and is a problem that only worsens over time. This warping issue, coupled with the propensity to rust, means the griddle top requires constant, diligent maintenance to remain usable, a commitment that may be more than some casual users are willing to make. For those who want to see its full feature set and user reviews, be aware that the cooktop is its most demanding feature.
Cooking Performance: Heat, Grease, and Glaring Design Flaws
With the grill finally assembled and seasoned, it was time to cook. We fired up all four H-pipe burners and were pleased with the raw power; it got ripping hot in minutes. Our first test was a classic: a massive batch of bacon. The heat was intense, and the bacon crisped up beautifully. However, the design flaws immediately came to the forefront. The warping issue caused all the rendered bacon fat to race to the perimeter of the griddle, away from the small, centered grease drain hole. This brings us to the single biggest design failure of the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill: the grease trap.
The included drip tray is comically small, no larger than a deck of cards. With just one pound of bacon, it was completely full and overflowing, sending hot grease dripping down the cart and onto our patio. This isn’t just a mess; it’s a genuine safety hazard. For any cook involving fatty meats like burgers or bacon, you must be prepared with a separate, larger container to catch the runoff. While the grill can produce decent results—our smash burgers developed a fantastic crust thanks to the high heat—you are constantly fighting against its design. The flimsy cart feels unsteady, the short stature makes it slightly awkward for taller chefs, and the disastrous grease management means cleanup is a guaranteed ordeal. It works, but it makes you work for it in ways a well-designed grill simply shouldn’t.
What Other Users Are Saying
Our experience with the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill aligns closely with the highly polarized feedback from the user community. The reviews paint a picture of a manufacturing lottery. On one side, you have users who, despite some flaws, find value. One user noted, “It works as it should but…the grease trap is TINY! Every time we use it the grease falls on the ground.” This sentiment captures the essence of the product: functional at its core, but deeply flawed in its details. Another user provided a helpful tip for the infamous paper on the griddle: “It’s actually waxed paper stuck to the oil… turn on the griddle till it heats up. Squirt with water and give it a quick scrub. Comes right off.” This highlights the “fixer-upper” nature of the grill.
Conversely, the negative feedback is severe and points to a systemic lack of quality control. One user’s summary was scathing: “Opened box and its missing instructions and one gas knob… EVERYTHING is bent and holes do not line up.” Another bluntly stated, “Truly a piece of crap. Plancha cast iron grill top warps and doesn’t sit level.” These aren’t minor complaints; they are fundamental failures in manufacturing and design that can render the product unusable or, at the very least, intensely frustrating right out of the box. The recurring themes are bent parts, rust, warping, and the disastrous grease trap, confirming that our testing unit was not an anomaly but representative of a common customer experience.
How Does the Gas One Grill Stack Up? A Look at the Competition
When considering the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill, it’s crucial to understand where it sits in the broader market. It competes in a space where price is a major factor, but performance and reliability can vary wildly. Let’s see how it compares to three distinct alternatives.
1. Cuisinart 4-Burner Gas Grill 44,000 BTU
- POWERFUL BURNERS: Four 11,000 BTU burners deliver a total of 44,000 BTUs of heat for precise, even cooking.
- SPACIOUS COOKING: 443 square inches of primary cooking space with an additional 167 square-inch warming rack for extra versatility.
The Cuisinart 4-Burner Gas Grill represents a more traditional path for the outdoor cook. This is not a flat top griddle but a classic propane grill with cast iron grates. For those who prioritize pronounced sear marks on a steak and the smoky flavor that comes from drippings vaporizing on flavorizer bars, the Cuisinart is a superior choice. It’s designed for a different style of cooking entirely. Someone might prefer this alternative if they value the reliability and established brand reputation of Cuisinart and their primary cooking involves classic grilling rather than griddling. It offers a more robust build quality and features like side tables, making it a better fit for a permanent patio fixture rather than a portable, multi-purpose cooker.
2. Char-Broil 1-Burner Portable Propane Grill
- GAS GRILL: Powered by liquid propane gas, this grill runs on a 1-pound propane gas tank, not included. It reaches cooking temperatures quickly, delivers...
- COOKING AREA: Grill up to 10 burgers, 4 chicken breasts or 14 brats on a 240-square-inch grate.
The Char-Broil 1-Burner is on the opposite end of the spectrum from the Gas One grill. Its primary design goal is maximum portability. With a single burner and a much smaller cooking area, this grill is built for tailgating, camping for one or two people, or cooking on a tiny apartment balcony. It sacrifices the massive capacity of the Gas One for ultimate convenience and a tiny footprint. A user would choose the Char-Broil if their number one priority is the ability to easily pack up their grill and take it anywhere. It’s not meant for cooking a dozen pancakes; it’s meant for grilling a few burgers at the park before the game, a task for which the large and cumbersome Gas One is ill-suited despite its “portable” cart.
3. Masterbuilt MB20030819 Portable Propane Grill
- 288 square inches of total cooking surface
- 10,000 BTU stainless steel U shaped burner for maximum heat distribution
The Masterbuilt Portable Propane Grill strikes a balance between the other two alternatives. It offers more cooking space than the ultra-portable Char-Broil but is far more compact and travel-friendly than the Gas One, thanks to its folding legs. It features a traditional grate system but provides a respectable 288 square inches of cooking space, making it a great option for small families on the go or RVers. A consumer would choose the Masterbuilt if they need more capacity than a tiny portable grill but still require a unit that is genuinely easy to transport and store. It offers a solid middle ground, providing better build quality and portability than the Gas One, though it lacks the sheer cooking volume and versatility of a flat top surface.
The Final Word: Is the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill a Bargain or a Bust?
After extensive testing and careful consideration, our verdict on the Gas One 4-Burner Flat Top Grill is a resounding “buyer beware.” This is a product defined by a fantastic concept—a large, powerful, portable flat top at a rock-bottom price—that is severely undermined by poor execution and non-existent quality control. It can, with significant effort, be made to cook food effectively. However, the journey to get there is fraught with potential frustrations, from a difficult assembly with bent and misaligned parts to a griddle top that warps and a grease trap that is fundamentally unfit for its purpose. This is not a grill for someone who wants a reliable, hassle-free appliance.
We can only recommend this grill to a very specific type of person: the budget-conscious DIYer who is comfortable troubleshooting, bending metal back into shape, and implementing their own solutions to design flaws (like a better grease-catching system). If you are willing to accept the gamble and potentially put in some work, you might get a functional, large-capacity griddle for a fraction of the cost of its competitors. For everyone else, the potential for disappointment is simply too high. We strongly advise saving up for a model from a more reputable brand, as the extra cost will likely save you a great deal of time and frustration. If you’ve read this far and still feel the potential reward outweighs the considerable risk, you can check the latest price and availability online.
Last update on 2025-11-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API